Mick Cleary's piece on England's rugby performance in Argentina is a fascinating read, offering a blend of analysis and personal commentary. The article delves into the team's journey, highlighting both their strengths and weaknesses. Here's a breakdown of the key points and my thoughts on them:
The Opening Salvo
England's dynamic and purposeful start in Santiago del Estero was a sight to behold. It showcased the potential that the team possesses, but it also revealed a half-built edifice. The article points out that a single moment of turbulence or panic can set the team back, which is a critical observation. Personally, I think this is a crucial aspect of any team's development - the ability to bounce back from setbacks is what separates the good from the great.
Discipline and Pressure
The issue of discipline is a legitimate concern, with England accumulating yellow cards across the last ten tests. This is a significant problem, and it's interesting to see how Borthwick handles the pressure. In my opinion, the team needs to tighten their discipline if they are to advance to the upper echelons of the world game. It's a delicate balance, though, as the team needs to maintain its aggression and intensity without crossing the line into indiscipline.
The Impact of Selection
The article also touches on the selection process, with Borthwick lagging behind other countries in giving young players a chance. This is an unfair criticism, as Borthwick has had very little room to maneuver. However, it's a valid point that the team needs to develop a deeper bench of proven players to ensure consistency and depth.
The Fundamentals
Despite the issues, Borthwick has laid the fundamentals for a strong team. A sturdy scrum and a fully functioning lineout are essential for any rugby team, and England has achieved this. It's a testament to the hard work and dedication of the players and coaching staff.
The Back-Line X-Factor
The back-line is a source of X-factor ability, with players like Manny Feyi-Waboso and Tommy Freeman showcasing their pace and strength. George Furbank could complete a back three that would compete with the best in the world. This is a crucial aspect of the team's success, as a strong back-line can create opportunities and exploit them effectively.
The Way Forward
Overall, Borthwick ends a long, long season in a reasonable place. It's a plus compared to the seditious mood growing through the Six Nations. The Nations Championship, particularly the outcome in Santiago del Estero, has given him breathing space and a springboard of possibility for what lies ahead. However, the team needs to address its issues with discipline and selection if it is to achieve its full potential.
In my opinion, the key to England's success lies in finding the right balance between aggression and discipline, and between experience and youth. It's a delicate dance, but with the right leadership and commitment, the team can achieve great things.
